1.TOUCHING MUKTZA THE S"A SAYS ITS ASUR THE REMA SAYS ITS MUTER.THE M"B SAYS MANY RISHONIM AGREE WITH THE S"A.
2.THE CHASAM SOFER SAYS MUKTZA OF FOOD IS MORE SERIOUS WE ARE WORRIED IF YOU TOUCH IT YOU MAY EAT IT BUT THE S"A HARAV ARGUES.
3.MOVE NOT MOVE MUKTZA OUT OF PLACE CONTINUES EXISTING LIKE THE SHABBOS CLOCK WHEN THE LIGHT STAYS ON THE POSKIM SAY THAT IS OK B/C THEIR IS NO PROBLEM OF CARRYING SO WE ARE MAKAL BUT SOME POSKIM LIKE THE MINCHAS YITZCHAK ARE MACHMIR.
4.THE POSKIM ASK WHY DOES THE CHALLAH ON THE TABLE ALLOW YOU TO MOVE THE TABLE WITH THE LEICHTER ON IT THE LEICHTER MORE VALUABLE?ONE ANSWER ISWE NEED THE CHALLAH SO IT HAS MORE VALUE OR ANOTHER ANSWER IS THE FLAME IS EQUAL IN VALUE TO THE CHALLAH.
Wednesday, April 2, 2014
RABBI ELEFANT'S DAF INSIGHTS 1ST DAF BEITZA DAF 2
1.TOUCHING MUKTZA THE S"A SAYS ITS ASUR THE REMA SAYS ITS MUTER.THE M"B SAYS MANY RISHONIM AGREE WITH THE S"A.
2.THE CHASAM SOFER SAYS MUKTZA OF FOOD IS MORE SERIOUS WE ARE WORRIED IF YOU TOUCH IT YOU MAY EAT IT BUT THE S"A HARAV ARGUES.
3.MOVE NOT MOVE MUKTZA OUT OF PLACE CONTINUES EXISTING LIKE THE SHABBOS CLOCK WHEN THE LIGHT STAYS ON THE POSKIM SAY THAT IS OK B/C THEIR IS NO PROBLEM OF CARRYING SO WE ARE MAKAL BUT SOME POSKIM LIKE THE MINCHAS YITZCHAK ARE MACHMIR.
4.THE POSKIM ASK WHY DOES THE CHALLAH ON THE TABLE ALLOW YOU TO MOVE THE TABLE WITH THE LEICHTER ON IT THE LEICHTER MORE VALUABLE?ONE ANSWER ISWE NEED THE CHALLAH SO IT HAS MORE VALUE OR ANOTHER ANSWER IS THE FLAME IS EQUAL IN VALUE TO THE CHALLAH.
No comments:
Post a Comment