Sunday, May 17, 2009
MISHNA BERURAH YOM I MISHNA BERURAH DIRSHU MAY 16 PART 2
S"A SIMAN 199 MISHNA BERURAH SIF KATAN 13
Children are not obligated in mitzvos so they should do zimun by themselves
Mishna BERURAH Dirshu Chelek 2
Q:Does chinuch help what about hearing zimun from 3 adults or 10 adults
A:From a din of chinuch the Mamer Mordichi and Kesef Mishna say he patur but Meri Brachos brings a Yash Mi Sheomar who says that children are like women and brings a Yash Mi Sheomar who says that children are like women and should do
zimun
A kid who hear zimun from 3 adults Rav Chaim Kineivski says you dont have to be machnech them to answer we are not tikun chinuch on kids with regards to zimun
but if he hears it from 10 people The S"T SHEVET Halevi concludes that they are able to answer with HASHEM name its no worse then teffila and berachos which they willbe obligated in when there adults which is a big rule in chinuch if there obligated as adults we michanach them in the mitzva when there kids
No comments:
Post a Comment