The Daf Yomi - In-depth practical case-study analyses derived directly from each day’s Daf. MAKKOS DAF 10 THE BLOOD OF THY BROTHER

L"N Chaya Sara bas BARUCH MORDECHI(TANTE)

Q:Is the goal hadam not ciev misa for killing his relative killer when there is circumstantial evidence to the killing of his relative or 1 witness to his relative death and if an Hatzalah member got to a car accident or heart attack of someone who killed his relative would he not have to save him

A:The Taz says the goal hadam can kill his relative killer based on circumstantial evidence and the Meri says the goal hadam can kill his relative killer based on 1 witness he is not ciev misah.Based on a Ketzos the Hatzalah member maybe does not have to save the killer of his relative