Choshen Mishpat Through the Lens of The Daf Yomi CHULIN DAF 59 NYC WATER AND BUGS

Q:IF THEIR IS A REASON TO BE MAKIL BY NEW YORK CITY WATER CAN WE BE MAKIL FOR EXAMPLE YOU CANT SEE THE BUG UNLESS YOU HAVE A SPECIFIC CUP OR LETS SAY THE BUGS HATCHED IN THE WATER.

A:IN THE 1ST CASE WE THE POSKIM SAY SAFAK DIURISSSA LECHUMRA SO WE ARE MACHMIR BUT IN THE 2ND CASE THE POSKIM SAY ITS NOT CONSIDERED A SHERETZ NEVERTHELESS ITS GOOD TO BE MACHMIR