BAIS HAVAAD'S THE DAF IN HALACHA PESACHIM DAF 107 What Qualifies for Chamar Medina

HARAV LEIBEL WILLIGER BRINGS THE S"A HARAV WHO SAYS WATER IS NOT CHAMAR MEDINA.SOME POSKIM SAY COFFEE AND TEA IS CHAMAR MEDINA BUT SOME POSKIM SAY IT IS NOT.THERE IS ALSO A MACHLOKES IN THE POSKIMABOUT MILK BEING CHAMAR MEDINA.THE POSKIM ARE MACHMIR BY SODA ITS NOT CHAMAR MEDINA.HARAV WILLIGER BRINGS A TESHUVA FROM RAV MOSHE WHO SAYS SODA IS NOT CHAMAR MEDINA B/C ITS LIKE WATER IT COOLS YOU ON A HOT DAY.RAV MOSHE THEN BRINGS THE A"H WHO SAYS HOT TEA HAS A DIN OF KAVOD.THEN HE BRINGS THE A"A WHO SAYS IN A SHAS HADACHAK YOU CAN BE MAKIL AND TEA AND MILK IS CHAMAR MEDINA.THE M"B SAYS NOT TO USE TEA OR MILK FOR KIDUSH OR HAVDALAH.THE MUNCHACKER RAV SAYS NOWADAYS WINE IS ALL OVER SO USE CHAMAR MEDINA.SOME POSKIM SAY BEER IS CHAMAR MEDINA B/C IT HAS ALCOHOL IN IT BUT THE CHAZONISH SAYS IT IS NOT CHAMAR MEDINA.FOR THE REST OF THE SHUR CLICK HERE.