DAF SUGYA WITH RABBI ELEFANT SHEKALIM DAF 2 ADAR RISHON ADAR SHENEI 1

RABBI ELEFANT ASKS 2 QUESTIONS OUR GEMARA SAYS HESPID AND TANNIS ARE ASSUR IN ADAR RISHON WHERE DOES THE REMA GET MAKE AN EXTRA SUDAH ON PURIM KATAN AND FURTHER MORE ITS APPROPRIATE HAVE THE EXTRA SUDAH ON THE 14TH OF ADAR RISHON BUT THE QUESTION IS SHOULDN'T IT BE CONNECTED IF YOU LIVED IN NON WALLED CITY YOUR EXTRA SUDAH SHOULD BE ON THE 14TH BUT IF YOU LIVE IN A WALLED CITY YOUR EXTRA SUDAH SHOULD BE ON THE 15TH ADAR RISHON BUT THATS NOT WHAT THE REMA SAYS.THE M"B BRINGS THE PM"G NO EXTRA SUDAH ON 15TH OF ADAR RISHON.ANSWER 1ST QUESTION THE GR"A SAYS THE CIUV OF EXTRA SUDAH TRAVELS TOGETHER WITH NO HESPED AND TANNIS.MINCHAS YITZCHAK DISCUSSES OUR 2ND SHILAH THE SEMAK SAYS THE REMA IS REFERRING TO SOMEONE WHO LIVES IN A NON WALLED CITY FOR HIM PURIM KATAN IS THE 14TH OF ADAR ISHON.AN INDIVIDUAL WHO LIVES IN WALLED CITY CELEBRATES PURIM KATAN ON THE 15 OF ADAR.MINCHAS YITZCHAK SAYS THIS PISHAT NOT SO SIMPLE IN THE REMA AND HE QUOTES THE PM"G WHO DOES NOT UNDERSTAND THE REMA THAT WAY.1 PISHAT PERHAPS IS THAT IT IS VERY MUCH CONNECTED TO OUR GEMARA.OUR GEMARA SAYS PEOPLE WHO CELEBRATE PURIM ON 15TH OF ADAR CAN READ THE MEGILLA ON THE 14TH OF AADR AND THEY WOULD BE YOTZA BUT WE DON'T WANT TO UPROOT THE READING OF THE MEGILLA ON THE 15TH OF ADAR SO READ IT OVER.PISHAT REMA IS AS FOLLOWS ACTUAL PURIM CORECT ZIMAN WALLED CITY IS 15 OF ADAR READ MEGILLAH BUT HERE WE ARE TALKING ABOUT PURIM KATAN REMEMBER HALACHA THAT A PERSON CAN READ THE MEGILLA ON THE 14TH OF ADAR IN A WALLED AND BE YOTZA BY CELEBRATING PURIM KATAN ON THE 14TH OF ADAR RISHON AND NOT THE 15TH OF ADAR RISHON.FOR THE REST OF THE SHIUR CLICK HERE.