Tuesday, November 5, 2013

DAF SUGYA WITH RABBI ELEFANT SHEKALIM DAF 8 KIDUSH WINE PART 1

RABBI ELEFANT ASKS THE M"B IN HILCHOS SHABBOS SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE BUT THE S"A IN HILCHOS PESACH SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE FOR THE 4 CUPS?RAV SHTERNBAUCH SAYS WE CAN DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER AND SHABBOS KIDUSH.BY THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER YOU HAVE TO DRINK THE ENTIRE CUP OR THE MAJORITY OF IT BUT BY SHABBOS KIDUSH A CHEEK FULL IS FINE.THE BRISKER RAV SAYS THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER HAVE A CONCEPT OF CHARUS BEING FREE SO THE S"A SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE WE DONT HAVE A DIN OF CHARUS BY SHABBOS KIDUSH SO THE M"B SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE ALSO THE 1ST CUP OF THE SEDER IS A DIN OF KIDUSH SO DO NOT USE COOKED WINE.CAN YOUR WINE HAVE SUGAR IN IT FIND OUT HERE IN THE REST OF THE SHIUR.

No comments:

Post a Comment