|
Dear Yeshiva Family:
In this week's parshah we read about one of the most painful moments in the history of the Jewish people, the episode of the Golden Calf. While the people were in the camp, Moshe Rabbeinu and Yehoshua were still on Har Sinai. On their way down the mountain they begin to hear sounds rising from the camp.
The Torah describes the exchange between them (Shemos 32:17–18). Yehoshua hears the noise and says to Moshe, "Kol milchamah bamachaneh, It sounds like the noise of battle in the camp." Moshe responds that it is not the sound of victory, nor the sound of defeat. "Kol anes anochi shomea" – it is a troubling, disturbing sound that I hear.
Rashi explains that this was the sound of blasphemy and wild celebration, the kind of sound that pains and distresses the soul of someone who hears it. It was not the sound of a battle at all, but the noise of people who had lost their spiritual direction.
The Yerushalmi explains that Moshe's response carried a criticism of Yehoshua. Moshe was saying that if you are going to be the future leader of this nation, how can you not distinguish between the sound of war and the sound of spiritual collapse?
What exactly was Moshe expecting from him here? What mistake did Yehoshua make that warranted criticism?
Rav Shimon Schwab explains that Yehoshua indeed did understand that he was not hearing the sounds of a military battle. What he meant was that what he was hearing was a rebellion, a war being waged against Hashem.
Moshe Rabbeinu's response, was not correcting Yehoshua about what he heard, but about how to understand it. A leader must not only identify rebellion, he must understand the source of the rebellion. Is it coming from people who consciously wish to rebel? Or is it coming from people who are acting out of pain?
In this case, the people believed that Moshe Rabbeinu had died and that they had been abandoned in the desert. They felt lost and alone. A nation that had only recently left Egypt suddenly believed its leader had disappeared. From that place of despair and confusion they turned to the Golden Calf.
That kind of failure requires a very different response than a deliberate rebellion against Hashem. When someone rebels out of ideology, the issue is defiance. But when someone falls because of pain or despair, the problem is entirely different.
And this, Moshe Rabbeinu was teaching Yehoshua, is part of what it means to be a leader. It is not enough to identify that something is wrong. One must understand why it happened.
Very often the behavior we see on the surface is not the real story.
We see this pattern in many areas of life. When young people struggle with religion, it is rarely because someone simply woke up one morning and decided, out of curiosity or intellectual exploration, to abandon the life they were raised with. In most cases it is not driven by ideology at all. No teenager is staring out the window of the school bus and suddenly deciding that Plato or some philosopher proved that everything they were taught is wrong. And despite what people sometimes assume, it is usually not just hormones, rebellion for its own sake, or even the attraction of drugs and other temptations.
Of course, peer pressure exists. A teenager might experiment with something new, try out a different group of friends, or test a boundary here and there. That is part of growing up. But very few people throw away the entire lifestyle and value system they were raised with simply for a little bit of excitement or pleasure. Human beings do not usually dismantle their entire world just because something looks fun.
Much more often, when a person turns toward destructive behavior, including rebellion, addiction, or other forms of self-destructive choice, it is because they are trying to escape something deeper. There is pain, disappointment, loneliness, or a sense of being misunderstood or abandoned. The behavior we see on the outside is usually the symptom, not the disease. What we are witnessing is the outward expression of an inner struggle that began long before the visible rebellion appeared.
Someone in a leadership position, a rebbe, a boss, or certainly in one's own home, must recognize that the behaviors we see are very often not the real story, but the result of something deeper.
A leader must therefore learn to respond not only to the behavior that is presented, but to the cause of the behavior.
That, according to Rav Schwab, was Moshe Rabbeinu's message to Yehoshua. If you are going to lead this nation, it is not enough to see the final product, a nation that appears to be rebelling. You must understand what produced that rebellion.
Are these people rejecting Hashem out of defiance? Or are they acting out of fear, confusion, and the feeling that they have been abandoned?
The response to those two situations will be completely different.
Leadership therefore requires more than simply identifying problems. It requires the patience and the sensitivity to search for the source of the problem. Only when a person understands where the behavior comes from can he begin to guide it in the right direction. The more we try to understand the people around us, our children, our students, our friends, our spouse, the more we will be able to respond not only to their actions, but to the needs that lie beneath them. When we do that, we are not only correcting behavior; we are helping people find their way back.
Similarly, when listening to the voices of our enemies, it is important not only to hear what is being said, but to understand the root of where it is coming from. Many people appear at rallies claiming to be merely "anti-Zionist," presenting their arguments in political language that sounds respectable or intellectual. But very often that language is simply a platform, a socially acceptable way of expressing something much older and much darker. Beneath the political slogans there is frequently the same ancient hatred of Jews that has appeared in different forms throughout history. One of the lessons of leadership is to recognize not only the words that are spoken, but the source from which those words come. Only when we understand the root of what we are facing can we respond to it properly.
We are once again embroiled as a nation in a 'real war' on multiple fronts and Hashem should protect us all and end wars for all of us. There is little doubt that if this war with Iran continues for an extended period of time, the voices of criticism will grow louder. We will hear more and more protests about America's involvement and about the inevitable loss of life that comes with any war. Those voices will likely present themselves in the language of humanitarian concern and political debate. But it helps to recognize that responding to those arguments on their surface level — trying to prove how this conflict serves American strategic interests — often misses the point. Doing so risks treating the symptoms rather than the underlying illness. If the opposition is driven by something deeper, by hostility toward Israel or toward the Jewish people, then debating policy details will not really address the root of the issue. Understanding the source of what we are hearing is often more important than winning the argument itself. May we merit to develop that kind of sensitivity and wisdom in our own lives, to see beyond the surface, to understand the hearts of those around us, and to guide them with patience, compassion, and clarity. Have an amazing Shabbos!
Rabbi Moshe Revah Mrevah2@touro.edu | 
No comments:
Post a Comment