RABBI ELEFANT ASKS THE M"B IN HILCHOS SHABBOS SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE BUT THE S"A IN HILCHOS PESACH SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE FOR THE 4 CUPS?RAV SHTERNBAUCH SAYS WE CAN DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER AND SHABBOS KIDUSH.BY THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER YOU HAVE TO DRINK THE ENTIRE CUP OR THE MAJORITY OF IT BUT BY SHABBOS KIDUSH A CHEEK FULL IS FINE.THE BRISKER RAV SAYS THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER HAVE A CONCEPT OF CHARUS BEING FREE SO THE S"A SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE WE DONT HAVE A DIN OF CHARUS BY SHABBOS KIDUSH SO THE M"B SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE ALSO THE 1ST CUP OF THE SEDER IS A DIN OF KIDUSH SO DO NOT USE COOKED WINE.CAN YOUR WINE HAVE SUGAR IN IT FIND OUT HERE IN THE REST OF THE SHIUR.
Tuesday, November 5, 2013
DAF SUGYA WITH RABBI ELEFANT SHEKALIM DAF 8 KIDUSH WINE PART 1
RABBI ELEFANT ASKS THE M"B IN HILCHOS SHABBOS SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE BUT THE S"A IN HILCHOS PESACH SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE FOR THE 4 CUPS?RAV SHTERNBAUCH SAYS WE CAN DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER AND SHABBOS KIDUSH.BY THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER YOU HAVE TO DRINK THE ENTIRE CUP OR THE MAJORITY OF IT BUT BY SHABBOS KIDUSH A CHEEK FULL IS FINE.THE BRISKER RAV SAYS THE 4 CUPS OF THE SEDER HAVE A CONCEPT OF CHARUS BEING FREE SO THE S"A SAYS YOU CAN USE COOKED WINE WE DONT HAVE A DIN OF CHARUS BY SHABBOS KIDUSH SO THE M"B SAYS DO NOT USE COOKED WINE ALSO THE 1ST CUP OF THE SEDER IS A DIN OF KIDUSH SO DO NOT USE COOKED WINE.CAN YOUR WINE HAVE SUGAR IN IT FIND OUT HERE IN THE REST OF THE SHIUR.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment