|
Dear Yeshiva Family:
In this week's parsha, Parshas Tzav, the Torah discusses the Korban Todah, the offering brought as an expression of gratitude to Hashem. Chazal give this concept very clear parameters. The Gemara in Berachos (54b) teaches that there are four primary situations in which a person is obligated to give thanks: one who crossed the sea, one who traveled through the desert, one who was ill and recovered, and one who was imprisoned and went free[1].
What unites all of these cases is clear. Each one involves a situation of real danger. A person was placed in a circumstance where things could have gone wrong and yet, he emerged safely. The gratitude in this sense is a gratitude born out of rescue, out of being pulled back from the brink.
However, the Rabbeinu Bachya, in our parsha (6:2), adds an additional example. Aside from these cases, he writes that there are other moments of joy that warrant a Korban Todah, such as the joy of a Chosson and Kallah.
Now, can we pause for one second. A chosson and Kallah are not emerging from danger. There was no sea, no desert, no illness, no prison. On the contrary, this is a moment of pure simcha—a moment of building, of beginning, of life.
What, then, is the connection? Why would this be grouped together with those who were saved from a danger?
The Dangers of Bachelorhood
One could suggest that, in fact, the Rabbeinu Bachya is entirely consistent. Perhaps bachelorhood itself carries with it its own form of danger, a spiritual, emotional, and even existential danger, and marriage represents an exit from that state, a transition into a more grounded and protected stage of life. In that sense, the joy of a bride and groom is not entirely separate from the other cases; it too reflects a form of being brought out from a place of vulnerability into one of stability and wholeness.
However, perhaps there is a deeper way to understand this.
It is very possible that the four examples mentioned by Chazal were carefully chosen to teach us something fundamental about human nature.
Recognizing the Good in the Everyday
A person does not always appreciate what he has when he has it. It is specifically when something is threatened, when the difficulty becomes acute, that a person becomes fully aware of its value. Only after emerging from danger does one truly feel the goodness of what had previously been taken for granted.
In this sense, the four cases are not really about extraordinary experiences. They are about returning to what is ordinary.
Health. Freedom. Stability. Safety.
Only after illness does a person appreciate what it means to simply feel well. Only after imprisonment does one understand the gift of being able to move freely. Only after the uncertainty of the sea or the vulnerability of the desert does one appreciate the simple gift of standing on solid ground.
What the person is celebrating is not something new, it is the restoration of what was always there. But now, for the first time, he truly sees it. He is celebrating the beauty and joy of regular life! And it needs celebrating because nothing is regular!
We find a similar idea elsewhere. As the luchos were about to be broken, the Torah suddenly describes their greatness, the divine craftsmanship, the uniqueness of the writing. The verse states, "And the Luchos were the work of Hashem, and the writing was the writing of Hashem" (Shemos 32:16). We can explain there as well with this idea, only after something is lost does its true value become fully visible. What was once taken for granted is now understood in its full depth.
If so, perhaps the essence of a korban todah is not simply gratitude for deliverance from danger. It is, more deeply, a tribute of thanks for the gifts a person has been given all along—but offered at a moment when he is finally able to appreciate them fully. That level of recognition is often born when one comes close to losing what he once took for granted. The deliverance from danger is not itself the object of the gratitude; rather, it is what brings the blessing into sharp focus, for the newly awakened ability to value what one already possessed.
Gratitude at The Seder
This perspective can also help us approach a well-known question that often arises at the Seder. Why do we thank Hashem for taking us out of Egypt, if He is the One who placed us there to begin with? More broadly, people ask: if Hashem brings about a difficulty, why should we thank Him when it is removed? If someone causes harm and then fixes it, is gratitude really warranted?
But this question rests on a fundamental misunderstanding.
We are not thanking Hashem only for the moment of salvation, as if the preceding difficulty stands in isolation. Rather, we are expressing gratitude for the entire reality that He has given us. The very life we live, the body we inhabit, the years of health and stability we experience—these are all gifts that precede any moment of hardship.
When a person becomes ill and then recovers, the gratitude is not merely for the recovery. It is for the restored ability to live within a body that, for so long, functioned as it should—something that was always a gift, even if it went unnoticed.
Perhaps an analogy can help bring this into focus. Imagine someone entrusts you with something valuable—a car, for example—and allows you to use it freely for an extended period of time. At some point, they ask for it back, or even just for it to undergo necessary maintenance. One would not respond with resentment, but with appreciation for the entire period of benefit that was given.
Of course, this idea can be developed and refined further. But at the very least, it begins to shift the conversation. Gratitude is not limited to the moment of being saved; it is an acknowledgment of the ongoing gifts that were always there, and that we are only now learning to recognize.
Thanking Hashem for Basic Life
With this, we can return to the Rabbeinu Bachya.
We are learning that the Korban Todah is there to thank Hashem for life itself—the ability to live with a healthy body, the stability of simply standing on solid ground, the basic conditions that allow a person to function and live with dignity. These are not small blessings; they are the very foundation of everything else. A korban todah is not brought for something superficial—for a new possession or a passing success. It is designated specifically for those aspects of life that are most basic and most essential, the very things that a person is most likely to take for granted. Health. Stability. Life itself.
On that level, one must also place the gift of a spouse—a healthy, loving partner with whom to build a life. This, too, is not an added bonus or a passing joy, but one of the most fundamental sources of goodness a person can have, on the level of life itself!
Of course, the appropriate time to bring this recognition to the forefront is at the very beginning—when the relationship is just starting, when its full weight and potential can still be appreciated. At that moment, the Torah would direct a person to bring a korban todah.
When one is forced to stop and truly recognize these gifts, he realizes just how profound they are.
A second point emerges from this understanding.
Once we place a spouse in the same category as life itself—as something fundamental, something essential—we must also recognize that it carries the same challenge.
Human nature is that we grow accustomed to what is constant. A person wakes up each morning and says Modeh Ani, but the truth is that it is not said with the same feeling as it would be the morning after being saved from a life-threatening illness or a serious accident. In those moments, one suddenly becomes aware of the gift of life in a way that is sharp, real, and deeply felt.
But as time passes, that awareness fades. Life returns to being "normal," and what is most precious once again becomes something we take for granted. The same is true in marriage.
A person becomes accustomed to their spouse—the presence, the support, the countless acts of care and responsibility that are part of daily life. And. without the appropriate focus, slowly, almost without noticing, small negative things begin to take center stage. Minor irritations grow, expectations build, and one can lose sight of the larger picture. What is constant becomes invisible.
Chazal address this directly. The Gemara in Yevamos (63a) relates that Rav Chiya would honor and appreciate his wife, despite the fact that there were aspects of the relationship that were difficult. When Rav questioned him, he responded that while there may be challenges, one must recognize the good—the immense good—that one receives. A person must train himself to focus not only on what is lacking, but on what is being given.
That is the avodah.
However, once we understand that a spouse is truly on the level of life itself, the responsibility that follows becomes clear.
Life is not perfect. There are challenges, frustrations, and unexpected difficulties. Yet we do not reject life because of those moments. We continue to value it, to work through its challenges, and to recognize the overwhelming good that it contains. So too in marriage.
There will inevitably be moments that are difficult. There will be aspects that require patience, effort, and understanding. But those moments are not meant to define the relationship. A person must make a conscious effort to notice the good, to value it, and to keep it at the forefront. The danger is not the existence of challenges, but allowing them to take center stage while the far greater good fades into the background.
In truth, the good within a marriage almost always outweighs the difficulties—often by far. The avodah is to focus on that good, to give it proper weight, and to not lose sight of what one has been given.
We must not wait for a moment of loss to recognize what we have.
Perhaps this is what the Rabbeinu Bachya is teaching us.
A bride and groom bring a korban todah not because they have emerged from danger, but because they are entering into one of the greatest sources of good in a person's life.
Have an amazing Shabbos! Rabbi Moshe Revah Mrevah2@touro.edu
____________________________________________
[1] There is a discussion amongst the authorities if one can offer a Todah for any purpose or specifically these cases. But that is not the subject of our article. The Rabbeinu Bechaya obviously is of the opinion that these four are not exclusive.
| 
No comments:
Post a Comment