Monday, October 10, 2011

Choshen Mishpat Through the Lens of The Daf Yomi - In-depth practical case-study analyses derived directly from each day’s Daf. Chulin part 3 DAf 89-95 ISSUREI ACHEILAH

Q:CAN YOU TAKE MEDICINE ON PESACH WHEN THERE CHAMETZ IN IT?WHATS THE CHIDUSH OF THE BINAS ADAM BY EATING AN APPLE WITH A WORM IN IT? WHEN A PERSON HAS TO EAT MACHALOS ASUROS B/C OF SAKANOS NEFASHOS DOES IT MITAMTAM HALAV?DOES ONLY ISURA ACHILA MITAMTAM HALAV OR ALSO ISURA HANAH MITAMTAM HALAV? A:BY MEDICINE ON PESACH WITH CHAMETZ IN IT THERE ARE CHEMICALS IN THERE NOT FIT FOR EATING AND BY A LIQUID MEDICINE ITS NOT FIT FOR EATING EITHER YOU NEED WATER WITH IT.ACCORDING TO THE PM"G AND CHAZONISH SAY ITS MUTER BUT ACCORDING TO THE RAMBAM AND RAV HEINKIN ITS A PROBLEM SO ITS ASUR.THE BINAS ADAM CHIDUSH IS IF YOU EAT THE APPLE AND WORM TOGETHER ITS ONLY AN ISUR DIRABANAN.WHEN SOMEONE WHO IS IN A SITUATION OF SAKANOS NIFASHOS EATS MACHALOS ASUROS ITS A MACHLOKES IF IT MITAMTAM HALAV.THE POSKIM SAY A WOMAN IN THIS SITUATION SHOULDNT NURSE HER CHILD BUT THE RAMBAM SAYS ITS THE AVARA THAT CAUSES THE TIMTUM HALAV SO B/C NO AVARA HERE NO TIMTUM HALAV.BOTH ISURA ACHILA AND ISURA HANAH MITAMTAM THE LAV.

No comments: