Q:WHERE SHOULD YOU LIGHT YOUR CHANUKA MENORAH?
A:RAV GREENWALD BRINGS THE REMA WHO SAYS YOU SHOULD LIGHT BY THE WINDOW AND THE CHASSIDIM LIGHT BY THE DOOR.WHEN ITS NOT A TIME OF SAKANAH LIGHT OUTSIDE.RAV ELYASHIV WOULD GO TO MIR AND LIGHT OUTSIDE IN A GLASS BOX.THE ITUR SAYS IN TIME OF SAKANAH CHAZAL REESTABLISHED THE LIGHTING TO BE INSIDE AND THATS THE MINHAG OF KLAL YISRAEL.RAV ELYASHIV PASKINS LIGHT OUTSIDE.OUR MITZVA IS FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE HOUSE.IF YOU ARE IN CHUTZ LARETZ LIGHT INSIDE BUT IF YOU ARE IN ERETZ YISAEL LIGHT OUTSIDE.RAV MOSHE AND RAV SHLOMO ZALMAN AURBACH SAY THAT PEOPLE IN AN APARTMENT BUILDING SHOULD NOT LIGHT OUTSIDE B/C THERE WILL BE TO MANY LIGHTS GET CONFUSING.RATHER THEY SHOULD LIGHT INSIDE.AN INTERESTING PISAK THE CHAZONISH SAYS LIGHT ON THE INSIDE.
No comments:
Post a Comment